Chrome has no sort button for tabs. I have looked for one about once a year since 2015, usually at the end of a week when the bar is sixty favicons wide and I am sure I have the same page open twice. It is not there. Right-click a tab and the menu offers new tab to the right, pin, mute, duplicate, groups, close. Nothing puts the tabs in order. So "tab sorter" is really a search for an extension, and before you install one it is worth knowing what Chrome can do by itself, what a sorter changes, and why I stopped using one.
What "sort" means to the people searching for it
Three different wishes hide behind the same word.
By site. All the GitHub tabs next to each other, all the Google Docs next to each other. This is the most common one and the one sorter extensions do best, because the domain is right there in the URL.
Alphabetically by title. Rarer, and mostly asked for by people who name their documents carefully. For everyone else the title of a tab is whatever the page decided, and sorting on it puts "(3) Inbox" next to "(1) Slack" and nothing useful next to anything.
By when you last used them. The tabs you touched today on the left, the stale ones drifting right so you can close them in one sweep. This one is interesting because Chrome already does it, just not in the tab bar.
Knowing which of the three you want decides whether you need an extension at all.
What Chrome does on its own
No sort, but more movement than most people use.
- Drag. Click a tab and drag it left or right. Drag it off the bar and it becomes its own window. Drag it onto another window's bar and it joins that window.
- Multi-select. Ctrl+click tabs, Cmd on a Mac, to select several. Shift+click selects a range. A selected block drags as one unit, closes as one unit, and right-clicks as one unit. Select every tab from the same site and drag the block to the left edge. That is a by-site sort for one site in about three seconds.
- Keyboard move. Ctrl+Shift+PgUp and Ctrl+Shift+PgDn move the active tab one slot left or right. On a Mac it is still Ctrl, not Cmd, and PgUp is Fn plus the up arrow. Hold it down and the tab walks across the bar.
- Pin. Right-click, "Pin". Pinned tabs shrink to the favicon and lock to the left edge, in the order you pinned them. Mail, calendar and the chat app live here and never move, which means you never sort them.
- Tab search. Ctrl+Shift+A, Cmd+Shift+A on a Mac. It lists every open tab across every window, most recently used first, with a search box. This is the by-recency sort. It is a list instead of a bar, and a list is the better shape for it. The stale tabs sit at the bottom.
- Number keys. Ctrl+1 through Ctrl+8 jump to the first eight tabs by position, and Ctrl+9 jumps to the last. These are the reason I care where tabs sit at all. If the thing I need all day is tab three, I want it to stay tab three. Any automatic sorter breaks this, which is the first mark against them.
Hand-sorting a window with the multi-select trick takes under a minute. The trouble is not the minute. By lunch the order is gone again, because every new tab opens to the right of whatever you were on and nothing in Chrome puts it where it belongs.
What a tab sorter extension does
A sorter reorders the open tabs in the current window, usually by domain, with title and URL as alternatives. Most add a toolbar button for a one-off sort and an option to sort automatically every time a tab opens. Some also pull duplicate tabs together or close them. They do not close anything else, they do not save anything, and they do not touch other windows unless told to.
Three things to check before you install one.
Permissions. Sorting needs the tabs permission, which reads titles and URLs. It does not need "Read and change all your data on all websites". If the listing asks for that, pick another one. The Chrome tab organizer page explains what each permission grants.
Auto-sort. It sounds like the whole point and it is the setting I turned off within a day. With auto-sort on, a tab you just opened from a Slack link jumps away from where you opened it, to wherever its domain lives in the order. You look up and the tab you were about to click has moved out from under the cursor. Keyboard positions change every time. One-off sort on a button is the version that stays installed.
Tab groups. Chrome lets you put tabs in named, coloured groups, and a group is a contiguous block on the bar. A domain sort either has to break the groups to put same-site tabs together, or has to leave grouped tabs alone and sort only the loose ones. Check which. The tab groups guide covers how groups behave on their own. If you already use groups, you want the second behaviour or you want no sorter at all.
Sorting is not the same as organizing
Here is the opinion. A by-site sort is a view. It makes the bar easier to read for the next ten minutes. It does not help you work, because work is almost never by site. The flight you are booking is a Google Flights tab, two airline tabs, a hotel tab and a Reddit thread about the hotel. A domain sort spreads those across five clumps, and the tab from the same airline that belongs to last month's trip lands next to this one.
Grouping by task is what holds. Right-click, "Add tab to new group", name it "Porto", collapse it when you are done for the day. The clump has a name, it collapses to one chip, and new tabs you open from inside it stay inside it. The organize Chrome tabs guide goes through this scheme in full, and it is what I do instead of sorting.
The gap in grouping is the same gap as in sorting. Nobody files the loose tabs. By four o'clock there are twenty tabs at the right end that belong to no group, and tomorrow there are forty. Two kinds of tool close that gap.
Rule-based groupers match a domain to a group name. Everything on Jira goes to "Work". These are a sorter with named clumps, and they share the sorter's weakness. They know sites, not tasks.
Auto-groupers read the titles and URLs of what is open and build groups by topic in one click. WiseTabs is one of these. It leaves groups you already made alone and sorts only the loose tabs, which is the behaviour I wanted from a sorter and never got. The result is Chrome's own groups, so collapsing, the chip menu and saving all keep working. Sorting closes nothing; it only closes tabs when you save a group or window for later.
Which one to use
- You want the by-site view now and then, and you do not use groups. Install a sorter, keep auto-sort off, and sort on demand with the button.
- You want recency. Stop sorting the bar and use tab search. It is already in order.
- You want to find duplicates. Newer versions of tab search flag them, and a domain sort puts them side by side so you can see them. Either way, close them with Ctrl+W.
- You use groups, or you keep ending up with forty loose tabs. Skip the sorter. Group by task, pin the three tabs you need all day, and hand the pile at the right end to an auto-grouper.
A sort routine that holds
Mine, for the record. Pinned tabs on the left, never sorted. Two or three task groups, collapsed except the one I am in. Once a day, usually before I close the laptop, I deal with the loose tabs on the right. Shift+click the first and last, right-click, "Add tabs to new group", and either name it or let the auto-grouper split it up. The whole thing takes under a minute.
Before I settled on that I ran a domain sorter for about two months. The bar looked tidy in screenshots. It did not make any single afternoon easier, and the tab jumping cost me more than the tidiness returned. If you try one and feel the same way, the fix is not a better sorter. It is naming the clumps.